Showtime, Showtime, Showtime… we were once friends and I mean, really good friends. You had good shows and had a decent catalogue of films available on your OnDemand library. Dexter and The United States of Tara quickly became my first choices in Premium Television. I dedicated time out of my busy schedule to watch those shows when they premiered to ensure they got my necessary ratings points. I was a dedicated fan!
Then you pulled the rug out from under me bit by bit.
First, you declined to put Season 4 and 5 of Dexter on NetFlix Instant Play. This was, of course, incredibly inconvenient at first, but then I learned that you would be moving your content to the OnDemand library at the end of certain time period. So I waited… and waited.. and waited… and the show never appeared on the library. After the cliffhanger that was Season 3 of Dexter, I simply couldn’t wait around for you to tell me when I could see your show. I had to watch the show by other means, and I really didn’t want to, but Showtime forced me into it by denying me access to their content. HBO does that to me, but Showtime, you’re supposed to be different! (At least HBO has their HBOGo service that actually has their content online.)
And then the monstrosity that is the Season 4 finale of Dexter happened… and I’m not going to detail it out in this post, but I’m just going to say that I’m still not over it. It was an unnecessary plot twist. Completely. I’m still a fan of Dexter (despite last season’s awkwardness), but I will never find a justification for the Season 4 finale. I guess some people would consider that “good TV”, but really, it was just being over dramatic for the sake of being over dramatic. That character didn’t deserve what happened to her and I will never stop being upset about it.
But Season 5 of Dexter was decent. And season 6 was good despite the seriously awkward situation they’ve set up for season 7. So I’ve mostly forgiven Showtime for the season 4 finale. Not all the way, but mostly.
During the time I got into Dexter, I got into another Showtime show, The United States of Tara. For those of you who have never seen Tara (shame on you), its a half hour dramedy about a family who has to deal with the mother’s multiple personality disorder. The concept is unique, and the execution was beautiful. Every character was well constructed and the show stayed interesting from first episode to last. Before Tara, sitcom Moms were just “crazy”, as in being labeled a crazy woman instead of being clinically mentally unstable. Tara was the first sitcom of its time to put a mentally ill character in a starring role. The beauty of the show was that the title character Tara was treated with so much dignity and was always portrayed as a normal person with an abnormal disease, instead of becoming a caricature of a person. Her alter personalities were definitely extremes of certain personalities, but they were never caricatures either; they were all well constructed people inside of an already well constructed person. The entire Gregson family, including Max, Kate, and Marshall, were all well constructed characters as well as instantly relatable people and they all gelled like a normal, middle class family.
The United States of Tara ran for just three seasons, and left us fans with a cliffhanger. We’ll never know what happened to Tara, and if she ever got better. Or if Kate’s relationship with her new boyfriend would turn into something more serious. Or if Marshall ever came to terms with his ex-boyfriend’s death. Or if Max and Tara ever got to just have a normal relationship. Showtime allowed Diablo Cody to create these magnificent characters and then they killed them. Showtime killed my favorite TV family and I’ll never know what the future held for them. Never.
There’s a certain cruelty in canceling a good show, actually; when storytelling is done correctly, the viewer tends to forget that they are watching a story, the story just becomes a slice of life, even if those lives aren’t real. And we viewers get emotionally involved in these stories in ways we don’t even realize at first, these stories and characters and situations become real. TV families like the Gregsons of United States of Tara become a familiar family that you become to know and love, and they just become apart of your life. And for at least 30 minutes a week, we viewers willingly take time out of our lives to peek into the life of another, and during that time, those people are completely real. Completely. We viewers grow to know and love these characters, to hope with them and become sad with them, revel in their triumphs and become disappointed when they are, and then all of a sudden, some network executive decides to kill your characters. They just disappear without a trace, and we viewers are left feeling like our dog has ran away with our hearts. While its socially acceptable to mourn for the loss of a pet, its not to mourn for the loss of your favorite fictional television characters, so we viewers go through our mild depression in private. Stories are just that involving, especially the great ones that touch you on some level. I’m not ashamed to say that I was extremely sad with The United States of Tara was cancelled, because I believed in that show and in those characters. I had felt like I’d known that family for a long time and that they moved away all of a sudden without saying goodbye.
Cancelled shows leave without saying goodbye, and it sucks. I’d much prefer for a show to just run its course and end with a bunch of resolutions, even if they aren’t resolutions I like (I’m looking at you Will and Grace series finale). I just want to feel like my favorite characters had some type of a full life and had their life problems resolved. I guess that’s why one can say that I prefer movies over TV shows: movies end with resolutions.
I’m currently re-watching The United States of Tara on Netflix Instant right now (Showtime apparently never got around to moving all of their content to a permanent OnDemand database) and my anger towards Showtime has only deepened. The only reasons I still subscribe to Showtime are because of Dexter and The Borgious (and the fact that it’s only $10 extra a month, compared to HBO’s $25 dollar monthly fee). Even Showtime’s movie library has become considerably worse over the past two years. I blame it on the fact that they spent so much money for the rights to air The Twilight Saga, and they didn’t have anything spend much on any other movies to exploit.
Showtime, you need to get your life together. The next time you have an amazing show on your hands, don’t get rid of it in the midst of “rebranding”.